The Evolution of an Iconic Bookstore

Barnes & Noble’s Acquisition of Tattered Cover

In the storied landscape of American bookselling, few names evoke as much nostalgia and reverence as Tattered Cover bookstores.  Established in 1971 in Denver, Colorado, this independent haven for bibliophiles has weathered decades of changes in the industry, cultivating a unique cultural legacy. 

Recently, however,  news broke that Barnes & Noble, the largest retail bookseller in the United States, had made an offer to acquire Tattered Cover for $1.83 million. 

As someone who first discovered Tattered Cover during a business trip to Denver in the nineties and later reacquainted myself with its charm after moving to Denver in 2010, this development feels profoundly personal.

First Encounter: A Literary Oasis in Denver

It was the late nineties, and I was in Denver for business. After a long day of meetings, I decided to explore the city and stumbled upon Tattered Cover's iconic 16th Street Mall location. 

Walking through its doors was like stepping into another world. The store's warm wooden interiors, cozy reading nooks, and the intoxicating smell of books immediately transported me away from the corporate hustle. I spent hours wandering through its aisles, losing myself in the labyrinth of literature, a true sanctuary for the soul.

Reacquainted: A Homecoming in 2010

Fast forward to 2010, when life brought me back to Denver permanently. One of my first destinations was, naturally, Tattered Cover. By then, the store had evolved but retained its quintessential charm. 

In recent years the locations in McGregor Square in Denver’s LoDo District and in downtown Colorado Springs, both of which closed last year due to financial difficulties, were among my favorite haunts. 

The McGregor Square store, in particular, with its vibrant atmosphere, was a fitting replacement for the 16th Street Mall location, capturing the essence of the original while infusing it with modern vitality.

The Rise and Challenges of Tattered Cover

Tattered Cover's journey from its humble beginnings to a Denver institution is a testament to the vision and perseverance of its founder, Joyce Meskis. When she acquired the store in 1974, it was a small shop in Denver’s Cherry Creek North neighborhood. 

Under her stewardship, Tattered Cover expanded, gaining a reputation for its vast selection of books, knowledgeable staff, and commitment to community engagement. The store hosted countless author events and became a focal point for Denver's literary scene.

However, the landscape of bookselling began to shift dramatically in the 2000s. The rise of e-commerce giants like Amazon, along with changing consumer habits, put immense pressure on independent bookstores. 

Despite its storied past and loyal customer base, Tattered Cover was not immune to these challenges. The store changed hands several times, with Len Vlahos and Kristen Gilligan taking over in 2017, followed by Bended Page in 2020. Financial difficulties persisted, leading to the closure of several locations and ultimately, a Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing in October 2023.

The Barnes & Noble Acquisition: A New Chapter

In a move that has sparked both hope and concern, Barnes & Noble's bid of $1.83 million was accepted by Tattered Cover in June 2024. 

The deal includes the acquisition of Tattered Cover's five existing locations and inventory, with a commitment to operate the stores under their original name and retain most of the current employees. 

This acquisition aligns with Barnes & Noble CEO James Daunt's strategy of preserving independent bookstore brands while integrating them into a larger corporate structure.

For many, this development is bittersweet. On one hand, it ensures the survival of Tattered Cover, allowing it to continue serving the Denver community. On the other hand, there are legitimate concerns about the loss of true independence and the potential for further consolidation in the bookselling industry. 

The unique culture and ethos that Joyce Meskis fostered at Tattered Cover may face new challenges under corporate ownership.

A Legacy of Community and Culture

The legacy of Tattered Cover is one of community, culture, and a deep love for the written word. During its heyday, the store was not just a place to buy books but a gathering spot for like-minded individuals. 

Author readings, book signings, and community events filled its calendar, creating a vibrant cultural hub. The store's aesthetic—rustic wooden shelves, comfortable seating areas, and the welcoming ambiance—invited patrons to linger, explore, and connect.

Joyce Meskis's commitment to defending First Amendment rights and fostering a space for free expression and intellectual exploration set Tattered Cover apart. This spirit of independence and advocacy remains a cornerstone of its identity, even as it likely faces a new chapter under Barnes & Noble.

Looking Forward: The Future of Tattered Cover

As Tattered Cover transitions into this new phase, it is poised to become what interim CEO Brad Dempsey describes as "the nation's first true hybrid bookstore." This model aims to combine the heart and soul of an independent bookstore with the resources and infrastructure of a corporate entity. 

Barnes & Noble's track record with similar acquisitions, like Blackwell's in the UK, suggests that this approach can be successful, preserving the unique characteristics of the store while enhancing its operational capabilities.

For those of us who have cherished Tattered Cover over the years, this acquisition is a reminder of the evolving nature of the bookselling industry. It underscores the importance of adaptability and resilience in the face of change. 

As I reflect on my own journey with Tattered Cover, from my first serendipitous discovery in the nineties to my regular visits after moving to Denver, I am hopeful that this beloved institution will continue to thrive and inspire future generations of readers.

Tattered Cover's story is far from over. It is entering a new chapter, one that holds the promise of preserving its legacy while adapting to the realities of the modern marketplace. For now, I will continue to visit its familiar aisles, finding solace in the continuity of a place that has long been a beacon for book lovers like myself.

---

Join Us as a Great Books, Great Minds Supporting Member

Since January of 2020, Great Books, Great Minds has provided subscribers community, connection and conversation around books for free—no paywall. But our future relies on you. At $6.00/month or $60.00 per year, please help us sustain our vision of impacting one million readers worldwide by 2030.